This Tallahassee Shop Makes Victorian Candy By Hand & Serves The Creamiest Ice Cream In North Florida

Stop by Lofty Pursuits in Tallahassee and prepare to be tantalized.

It’s an ice cream shop, a Victorian candy factory, an old-fashioned soda fountain, a breakfast spot, and a nostalgic toy store all in one.

The shop is particularly famous for showing how candy was made using authentic techniques and equipment from the 1800s.

Whether you’re there for breakfast, a handcrafted sundae, or to watch candy being made, Lofty Pursuits delivers a one-of-a-kind experience every time.

Handcrafted Treats

The Victorian Candy: Take a bite out of history with their Victorian candy.

It’s made using authentic vintage equipment and traditional techniques from the 1800s. Each colorful piece is crafted with meticulous attention to detail, resulting in flavors so unique and vibrant they’ve developed a cult following nationwide.

The tangerine sours (a recreation of discontinued Altoids) and cherry limeade sours frequently sell out for good reason!

Homemade Ice Cream: This is quite possibly the best ice cream in all of Tallahassee!

And the extensive flavor selection will have you contemplating multiple visits just to try them all.

Once you’ve tasted their premium scoops, ice cream from other places just doesn’t compare.

Classic Fountain Specialties: The root beer floats here feature housemade root beer topped with rich vanilla ice cream.

For a truly authentic experience, try the Brooklyn egg cream or opt for a traditional banana split completed with homemade whipped cream.

Breakfast Worth Waking Up For: Don’t overlook their morning menu!

The avocado toast here comes loaded with “all the fun stuff,” while their gluten-free pancakes are also just as amazing.

Everything arrives with real butter, genuine maple syrup, and locally sourced ingredients like thick-cut bacon, fluffy homemade biscuits, and farm-fresh eggs.

Vegan & Dietary Options: They also have clearly labeled vegan ice cream flavors and syrups, plus gluten-free options that don’t sacrifice taste.

A Whimsical Atmosphere For All Ages

Nostalgic Time Capsule: The moment you walk in, you’re greeted by shelves of games and toys, while vintage ice cream scoops line the walls above a long counter.

The quaint tables and retro décor instantly transport you to a simpler, sweeter time in American history.

YouTube Fame: Look for their Silver Play Button on display. Because yes, this place actually has a lofty YouTube Channel as well!

Their popular YouTube channel has over 500,000 subscribers who tune in to watch their mesmerizing candy-making demonstrations.

Fun Activities: Beyond the sweet treats here, there are plenty of other fun things to explore.

Keep your eyes peeled for their wide selection of classic games, quirky toys, and even quarter dispensers scattered throughout.

It’s impossible to be bored while waiting for your order here.

Disc Golf Corner: Among the unexpected treasures is the Disc Golf corner within the shop, adding another layer of quirky charm to an already distinctive establishment.

Other Considerations

Surprising Value: Despite the artisanal quality and handcrafted nature of everything they serve, prices are remarkably reasonable.

Breakfast items rival chain restaurants like IHOP and Waffle House in affordability, with even their NY strip steak and eggs breakfast priced at just $16. And the candy itself is definitely worth the price considering how rare it is to find old-school candy these days.

Worth The Drive: If you’re not local to Tallahassee, consider incorporating this stop into your travel plans.

Online Shopping: Can’t make it to Tallahassee?

Their online store ships their famous handmade candies nationwide.

Best Souvenirs: The handmade candy here makes for unique gifts that recipients won’t forget.

Order the “leftovers” candy bags for a surprise assortment of delicious pieces at a great value.

---

Lofty Pursuits
📍 1355 Market St A11, Tallahassee, FL 32312
Google Maps Directions