See Why Pizza Fans Adore The Hand-Made Sesame Crust At This Spot In Orlando

Black Magic Pizza in Orlando’s Milk District is enchanting locals and tourists alike with their spellbinding New-Neapolitan style pizzas.

What started as a pandemic pop-up has transformed into one of Florida’s most talked-about pizza destinations.

Former New Yorkers claim it rivals their hometown favorites, while Orlando natives have found their go-to spot for a perfect slice.

With hand-tossed dough made in small batches, a perfect balance of sauce and cheese, and innovative flavor combinations, Black Magic Pizza is redefining what pizza can be in the Sunshine State.

Pizza That Will Cast A Spell On You

The Crust: The foundation of any great pizza, and Black Magic’s is nothing short of exceptional.

Their dough is mixed in small batches, creating a perfect hybrid between New York and Neapolitan styles.

The crust achieves that ideal balance – crispy and slightly charred on the outside with just the right amount of chewiness inside. If you’re from NYC then this pizza spot may remind you of home.

The Sauce: Perfectly balanced and bursting with fresh tomato flavor.

Not too sweet, slightly acidic, and seasoned just right.

The sauce-to-cheese ratio is consistently on point, never overwhelming the other components but making its presence known in every bite.

Dr. Pepperoni: This is a fan favorite that transforms the classic pepperoni pizza with a sweet and salty twist.

The perfect cup-style pepperoni gets crispy around the edges, while a spicy maple drizzle adds an unexpected but delicious flavor dimension that elevates it beyond the standard pepperoni experience.

White Iverson: Another crowd-pleaser featuring a sesame seed crust that adds amazing texture and a nutty flavor profile. This white pizza showcases Black Magic’s ability to create exceptional pies beyond the traditional red sauce varieties.

Vegan Options: Black Magic doesn’t leave plant-based eaters behind.

Because their vegan pizzas are even delicious to non-vegans, featuring the perfect amount of vegan cheese to avoid the common “slimy” texture issue. The same attention to detail given to their traditional pies carries over to these plant-based creations.

Beyond The Pizza

Garlic Knots: These aren’t your average afterthought appetizers.

Black Magic’s garlic knots are sizable, dripping with garlicky oily goodness, and served with their outstanding sauce for dipping.

They’re large enough that an order might be better shared unless you’re planning for leftovers.

Savory Wings: Wednesday is a special day at Black Magic with half-priced wings that have developed their own following.

The buffalo wings are just plain delicious. And the garlic parmesan consistently delivers mouthwatering flavor.

The portions are generous enough that they could serve as a meal on their own!

Poutine: Perhaps the most surprising menu standout here is their authentic poutine.

The brown gravy is just pristine, the cheese curds exceptional, and the fries strike an ideal balance between crispy exterior and soft interior.

Mozzarella Sticks: Crispy, well-seasoned, and filled with stretchy stringy cheese that pulls apart in that satisfyingly Instagram-worthy way.

Pair these with some marinara sauce and you’ll see why these are the most ideal deep-baked cheese rectangle you could ever ask for.

Holy Cannolis: Made with such care and authenticity that you’ll forget you got this at a pizza joint.

It’s a perfect sweet ending to a meal of savory perfection.

Atmosphere & Location

Pickup Window Style: Black Magic operates primarily as a pickup window, though there are a few tables available if you want to enjoy your pizza immediately.

The setup is simple but effective. They focus on the food rather than elaborate dining spaces.

Neighboring Establishments: One of the clever aspects of the location is its proximity to other complementary businesses. Whiskey Lou’s is right next door, allowing you to order pizza and enjoy it with drinks next door.

The Milkhouse is also nearby, offering options for coffee or ice cream after your meal.

Milk District Vibe: The location puts Black Magic right in Orlando’s hip Milk District, known for its eclectic mix of food and drink establishments.

The area has a forward-looking atmosphere that perfectly complements Black Magic’s approach to pizza.

Space Limitations: As a primarily takeout establishment, there isn’t much seating directly at Black Magic. Just something to note if you plan on eating in during busier times.

Other Considerations

Pricing: Black Magic falls on the higher end of the pizza price spectrum, but in general I’d say the quality justifies the cost.

You’re paying for small-batch dough, fresh ingredients, and careful preparation that elevates this beyond standard pizza chain fare.

Parking Situation: Being in the Milk District means parking can be somewhat limited.

Whiskey Lou’s does have a lot where spots are sometimes available, and there’s street parking in the area, though you might need to search a bit during busy times.

Ordering Tips: It’s worth ordering online for pickup rather than showing up and ordering in person. The online system is easy to use and helps streamline the process.

Operating Hours: Black Magic is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, so plan your pizza cravings accordingly. Wednesday is particularly popular due to their wings special.

Best For: While this place welcomes everyone, it seems particularly well-suited for casual dining, date nights, or grabbing food with friends before or after enjoying the Milk District’s bar scene.

Or if you’re just a big pizza fan!

The quality ingredients and creativity of the menu make this special enough for rare occasions while still being accessible for regular visits.

---

Black Magic Pizza
📍 121 N Bumby Ave, Orlando, FL 32803
Google Maps Directions