Turn Your Dessert Dreams Into Reality At This Bright Green Key Lime Pie Shop In Key West

Finding authentic Key lime pie in Florida might seem easy. But discovering the perfect balance of tart and sweet can be challenging.

Key West has you covered.

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shop has mastered this delicate balance to bring Florida’s most iconic dessert to your taste buds.

And it goes beyond just pie! This is a lime-lover’s paradise with a diverse array of Key lime-infused treats that will leave you wondering how you ever lived without them.

Must-Try Delights

The Classic Key Lime Pie: Prepare your taste buds for perfection!

This award-winning pie delivers the ideal balance of creamy sweetness followed by that signature tartness that true Key lime enthusiasts crave.

The graham cracker crust provides the perfect foundation for this iconic dessert. It could rightfully be considered among the best on the island.

Chocolate-Dipped Pie on a Stick: This is absolutely an Instagram-worthy treat so keep your phone on the ready.

The frozen Key lime pie dipped in rich dark chocolate creates an unexpected yet delightful combination that transforms the classic dessert into a portable, refreshing treat. Perfect for strolling through Key West on a hot afternoon.

Key Lime Ice Cream: Velvety smooth and perfectly balanced, the Key lime ice cream here offers a refreshing alternative to traditional pie.

It’s sweet, it’s tropical, and it’s a treat you’ll only find in Key West.

Specialty Flavored Pies: Beyond the classic version of Key Lime Pie, Kermit’s also offers innovative variations including strawberry Key lime and coconut Key lime pies.

These unique twists maintain the signature tartness while introducing complementary flavors that provide delightful alternatives for those seeking something different.

Key Lime Cookies: The sugar cookies here are a hidden treat that not everyone has tried, but they’re worth getting.

Soft, limey, and rolled in powdered sugar, these treats offer the perfect bite-sized burst of Key lime flavor that keeps customers coming back specifically for these delectable morsels.

Beyond Just Desserts

Unique Key Lime Products: The store also features an impressive array of Key lime-infused items extending far beyond desserts. From sauces and salad dressings to BBQ sauce (reportedly amazing on chicken!), jellies, candies, and even personal care products, you could spend hours browsing their selection.

Free Tastings: Kermit’s generously offers some samples of their products, allowing you to try before you buy. This tasting area lets you explore the full range of lime possibilities here, from savory to sweet. All from a whimsical environment adorned in shades of yellow and green.

Gift Options: Looking for the perfect Florida souvenir?

Kermit’s offers shipping services for their pies and various gift baskets filled with Key lime goodies, making it easy to share your discovery with friends and family back home.

Atmosphere & Décor

Secret Garden Oasis: There is a beautiful courtyard behind the main shop where you can order a slice and take it all in.

This tranquil space features lush hanging plants, a serene koi pond, and the gentle sound of running water. So if you have time for a sit down it’s well worth eating a slice of pie here.

Lime-Themed Ambiance: The shop embraces its theme wholeheartedly with lime green prominently featured throughout the décor.

The space feels authentic and thoughtfully designed, creating an immersive Key lime experience from the moment you step inside.

Indoor Comfort: The well-air-conditioned interior provides welcome relief from Key West’s heat and humidity. So take your time here while you’re looking around.

Other Considerations

Price Point: Kermit’s offers reasonable pricing for the quality received, especially since there isn’t much like it with this many unique treats.

Pro tip: If you’re planning to get more than four individual slices of pie, it’s cheaper to buy a whole pie and have it cut into however many slices you want (they will cut it for you so it’s effortless).

Elizabeth St. Location Advantages: This original Elizabeth Street location offers the full Kermit’s experience with the widest product selection.

While there is another location on Duval Street, only the Elizabeth Street shop features the complete bakery with all specialty items like the cookies.

Timing Your Visit: Being a popular destination for tourists and locals alike means Kermit’s can get busy, but it’s rarely so busy that you won’t be able to get a slice. Though there is limited seating in the garden area so keep this in mind if you want to sit and eat there.

Dog-Friendly: Pet owners will appreciate that the shop welcomes four-legged friends.

---

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shop
📍 200 Elizabeth St, Key West, FL 33040
Google Maps Directions