Over 50 Homemade Flavors Await You At Fort Myers’ Legendary Love Boat Ice Cream Shop

Love Boat Ice Cream has been scooping up frozen happiness since 1967. And it has been delighting locals and visitors alike from its spot along San Carlos Boulevard in Fort Myers the entire time.

This beloved local institution has perfected the art of homemade ice cream, offering over 50 unique flavors to try.

With its nostalgic charm and legendary portion sizes, this ice cream shop is a true Southwest Florida experience that deserves a visit at least once.

Flavor Paradise

The Selection: Prepare to be overwhelmed (in the best way) by the vast array of homemade flavors lining the display case.

From timeless classics to creative concoctions, the hardest part of your visit will be narrowing down your choices from the 50+ options available.

Blueberry Cheesecake: This flavor very well could bring grown adults to tears of joy. The perfect balance of tangy cream cheese base swirled with sweet blueberry ribbons creates an unforgettable taste sensation that captures the essence of a freshly baked cheesecake.

Salted Caramel Bacon: For the adventurous palate, this unexpected combination delivers a masterful blend of sweet, salty, and savory.

Yes, it contains real bacon pieces. And somehow it works brilliantly.

Oatmeal Cream Pie: Here’s a fan favorite that transforms the nostalgic cookie into a creamy delight. Each spoonful of the oatmeal cream pie flavor delivers the comforting flavor of oatmeal cookies with ribbons of marshmallow cream throughout.

French Raspberry Supreme: This sophisticated option pairs a luxurious cream base with vibrant raspberry swirls.

Seasonal Specialties: The menu evolves throughout the year with seasonal offerings that showcase Florida’s fresh ingredients and holiday inspirations.

These limited-time creations give even the most frequent visitors something new to discover.

Signature Servings

Generous Portions: “Small” is a relative term at Love Boat.

A small waffle cone comes loaded with four substantial scoops, allowing you to sample multiple flavors in one sitting.

Even their kiddie cone includes two hefty scoops.

Waffle Cones: Freshly made and perfectly crisp, these cones are the ideal vessel for the mountain of ice cream they support.

Sundae Splendor: The sundaes are architectural marvels of ice cream engineering.

A small sundae features three enormous scoops topped with your choice of toppings, while the large option doubles that with six scoops.

Charming Atmosphere

Nostalgic Setting: The retro-inspired decor creates an authentic old-fashioned ice cream parlor vibe that enhances the experience.

Clean, bright, and welcoming, this is one ice cream shop that maintains its classic charm while offering modern comforts.

Outdoor Options: Plenty of seating outside allows you to enjoy your ice cream in the Florida sunshine when the weather is pleasant. The patio area provides additional space during busy periods.

State Pride Books: Look for the binders organized by state where you can sign your name and see who else from your home state has paid a visit.

Worth Knowing

Price Point: Expect to pay between $7-$14 per person depending on your selection. While it’s not the cheapest ice cream around, it is certainly ice cream that you won’t forget, and you get a lot of it.

Portion Planning: Order smaller than you think you need! A small sundae is easily shareable between two people, and even the kiddie cone options are substantial.

Peak Times: Being a popular spot near the beach, expect lines during tourist season and on hot summer days.

Parking Considerations: The parking lot can fill up during busy periods, but spaces tend to open up regularly as customers finish their treats.

Multiple Locations: Love Boat has several spots throughout Fort Myers (including Sanibel Island) so you can get your ice cream fix all over the area.

---

Love Boat Ice Cream
📍 16475 San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908
Google Maps Directions